Best Multiple Cat Litters of 2025: Top 10 Picks Reviewed

The search for the perfect kitty litter can be daunting, especially when you have multiple cats. As someone who has two cats myself, I’ve gone through a lot of trial and error trying to find the best litter that my cats like, manages the odor of two litter boxes, and limits the amount of mess and tracking throughout my small Brooklyn apartment. Because my number-one priority is odor control (because my litter boxes are in the living room), I prefer natural materials, such as pine, that do a great job at masking the litter box odor while also being easy to clean up. 

However, not all cat households have the same priorities. When it comes to looking for multi-cat litters, you have to ask yourself what it is you want out of a litter and then go from there. There are so many factors to consider when looking for litter, including odor control and/or scent, texture, material, clumping or non-clumping, dust level, etc. While it’s tough to find a litter that checks 100 percent of your boxes, luckily there are some that come pretty close.

Navigating life with a new pet? Head to littleKin!

littleKin™ is Kinship’s home just for puppy and kitten parents. Bop over to check out expert advice, new pet tools, and special deals—all curated for your newest family member.

Get Free Advice

Btw, our editors (and their pets) picked out these products. They’re always in stock at the time we publish, but there’s a chance they’ll sell out. If you do buy through our links, we may earn a commission. (We’ve got a lot of toys to buy over here, you know?)

How to choose the multi-cat litter that is right for you:

• The material used for litter is a good place to start when finding the right one for your cats. There are many different types of litter on the market, including clay, silica gel, corn-based, tofu, and many more. Finding a texture that your cat likes is a great way to find the best material for them. 

• Odor control is a huge component when it comes to choosing a litter, especially for multi-cat homes, and sometimes that means deciding between scented and unscented litters. Scented litters use deodorizers to help cover up the smell, but sometimes the addition of a scent can be overwhelming for cats since their noses are much more sensitive than ours. “Unscented” litters aren’t truly scentless. There are just no added scents; so, it can sometimes be a trade off when using unscented litter between your cat’s comfort and the scent that might still emanate from the litter box. 

• Dust is also a major factor when it comes to litter — and how much of it is tracked when cats leave the litter box. If your cat has feline asthma, making sure to find litters that aren’t likely to track a lot of dust is very important. 

• Weight can also be something to consider when choosing a litter. Some litters are very heavy and may require more effort when you take them home from the store. 

Our top cat litters for multiple cats picks

We’ve searched for the best multi-cat litters available in order to meet any and all of your cats’ needs. Whether you prefer clay or plant-based, clumping or non-clumping, there is something for every cat on this list. 

Best overall: Arm & Hammer Litter Slide Multi-Cat Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

Best clumping: Arm & Hammer Litter Multi-Cat Strength Clean Burst Clumping Litter

Best non-clumping: Feline Pine Original Non-Clumping Wood Cat Litter

Best scented: Fresh Step Febreze Freshness Gain Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

Best unscented: Ever Clean Extra Strength Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

Best flushable: World’s Best Low Tracking & Dust Control Multiple Cat Litter

Best clay: Dr. Elsey's Ultra Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

Best crystal: PrettyLitter Health Monitoring Cat Litter

Best grass: Catit Go Natural Multi Cat Vanilla Scented Pea Husk Clumping Cat Litter

Best corn: Nature's Miracle Premium Scented Clumping Corn Cat Litter

Best overall

Arm & Hammer Litter Slide Multi-Cat Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

$35

Arm & Hammer is a staple in the cat litter game for a reason, and their Slide Multi-Cat litter comes highly recommended from pet shelters and average consumers alike. A brand known for making baking soda naturally comes with rock solid odor control, which is exactly what you need when you’re trying to contain the litter box smells from multiple cats. This clumping litter is also nonstick, so it should scoop out of your litter box easily rather than sink to the bottom and get stuck, as well as 99.9% dust free.

$35 at Amazon

Pros

• Nonstick, clumping, clay litter

• 99.9% dust free

• Low tracking

• Comes with a seven-day odor-free guarantee

Cons 

• Clay litter not preferred by all homes

• Packaging doesn’t always stand up to shipping

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

Overall review

We love that this litter is not only clumping, but it’s also nonstick, ensuring your scooping experience will be seamless. Its odor control is top notch, and we also love that it’s 99.9& dust free and low tracking. Just be warned that due to the cardboard packaging, it sometimes won’t stand up as well to shipping. 

Review rating: 5/5

Best clumping

Arm & Hammer Litter Multi-Cat Strength Clean Burst Clumping Litter

$20

While this is a clay litter, it combines with baking soda crystals to provide the ultimate odor control via hard clumps. Its clumping formula also makes scooping easy and keeps your litter box clean.Plus, it’s 99.9 percent dust-free, low tracking, and designed specifically for managing the litter boxes for multiple cat households.

$20 at Chewy

Pros

• Clay litter that combines baking soda crystals with ammonia odor neutralizers

• Hard clumps that help with scooping and odor control

• 99 percent dust-free

• Low-tracking

Cons 

• Scented litters not preferred by all

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

Overall review

We love how effective this clumping litter is at keeping litter boxes both clean and fresh. Its formula that utilizes baking soda really does cut down on the stench, and the fact that it’s also 99 percent dust free and low tracking is icing on the cake. However, it is technically scented, so if you don’t like stronger smells added to your litter box set up, this might not be the one for you and you cats. 

Review rating: 4.5/5

 Best non-clumping

Feline Pine Original Non-Clumping Wood Cat Litter

$22

This natural, non-clumping litter is incredible at odor control. The natural pine materials effectively masks and neutralizes the cat urine scent, and also absorbs moisture super well to break down in the litter box. While this isn’t a clumping litter, cleanup is still easy as it’s lightweight and less likely to stick to the sides and you can simply dump the litter once it’s been properly used.

$22 at Amazon

Pros

• Natural pine fibers lock away ammonia odors and neutralize them on contact

• Non-clumping and lightweight pine makes litter box clean-up easy

• Low-tracking

Cons

• Non-clumping litter not preferred by all

Overall review

I will admit that I am fully a pine litter convert, and this is my preferred choice when it comes to keeping my two cats’ litter boxes fresh. I love the natural pine scent and how effective it is at neutralizing the cat pee odor in my home. I never thought I would be on the non-clumping litter train, but after using this litter I’ve found cleanup is just as easy as clumping litter, as you can simply dump the litter box once it’s reached the end of its freshness. And because its dry form is in pellets, the tracking and dust is super low. 

Review rating: 5/5

Best scented

Fresh Step Febreze Freshness Gain Scented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

$25

Febreeze is basically synonymous with “fresh,” so it only makes sense that a Febreeze collab with litter would come out on top when it comes to scented litters. This clay litter teams up with both Febreeze and Gain to create a formula with carbon, Ammonia Block technology, and Febreze freshness for ultimate odor control. Its fast absorption into hard clumps also keeps litter boxes dry and clean for easy scooping.

$25 at Chewy

Pros

• Clay formula with carbon, Ammonia Block technology, and Febreze for odor control

• Low dust

• Gain scent that is activated by cats’ paws upon touch

Cons

• Still can kick up some dust in the home

• Added scents not preferred by all

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

Overall review

If you love that fresh laundry smell, this is the scented litter for you. We love this fresh formula that combines the benefits of clay litter with the refreshing scent of Febreeze for ultimate odor control. Plus, it has continuous odor control with the Gain scent that gets activated every time your cats touch and dig into the litter. However, even though it’s advertised as dust free, some reviewers have mentioned that it does still kick up some dust. 

Review rating: 4.5/5

Best unscented

Ever Clean Extra Strength Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

$23

This unscented litter uses activated charcoal rather than added scents to neutralize odors coming from the litter box for up to 14 days. It also creates tight clumps to help with odor control as well as keeping litter dry and easy for scooping. Plus, it is low-dust and low-tracking. 

$23 at Chewy

Pros

• Clay litter with Ammonia Shield and CarbonPlus technology for 14-day odor control

• Low-dust

• Low-tracking

Cons

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

• Not best for robot litter boxes

Overall review

If added scents aren’t your thing, this unscented litter is the way to go. We love that it uses activated charcoal and Ammonia Shield to help neutralize odors rather than using added scents and deodorizers. The fact that it can keep your litter box fresh for up to two weeks is a huge plus. However, though it does boast to be low dust and low tracking, it still might kick up some dust according to some reviewers. 

Review rating: 4/5

Best flushable

World's Best Low Tracking & Dust Control Multiple Cat Litter

$23

$20

If your multi-cat litter box setup tends toward the messier side, this World’s Best litter designed specifically to cut down on tracking and dust control is a must. This litter doesn’t release fine particles and is 99 percent dust-free. Made from corn, its natural odor control is great, and it is also safe to flush in most septic and sewer systems, making scooping that much easier. 

$20 at Amazon

Pros

• All natural corn-based litter free from harmful chemicals and artificial perfumes

• Low-tracking and doesn’t release fine particles 

• 99 percent dust-free

• Flushable and safe for most septic and sewer systems

Cons 

• Natural scent might not be preferred by all households

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

Overall review

World’s Best is a tried-and-true brand when it comes to kitty litter, and this low-dust and low-tracking litter is perfect for multi-cat homes. Its natural materials also lend to it being flushable, which makes scooping especially easy if you keep the litter box in or near your bathroom. We love that this corn-based litter is safe for pets and also doesn’t need to use added ingredients to help with odor control. However, some reviewers have mentioned that the natural scent might be too strong or not a desirable scent for some households. 

Review rating: 4.5/5

Best clay

Dr. Elsey's Ultra Unscented Clumping Clay Cat Litter

$12

Dr. Elsey’s has become quite the go-to clay litter on the market, especially for multi-cat households. It provides hard clumping for easy scooping and has great odor control without using any added scents. Plus, it’s 99 percent dust-free and has minimal tracking.

$12 at Amazon

Pros

• Made with 100 percent bentonite clay, with a medium granule size for hard clumping

• 99 percent dust free

• Low -racking

• Odor control via natural ingredients

Cons 

• Low -racking is dependent on more frequent scooping/litter box maintenance

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

Overall review

This Dr. Elsey’s litter is one that I’ve tried with my own cats to great success. I love that it comes in big bags so I don’t have to replenish my litter too often. It’s low-dust, low-tracking, and the odor control is one of the best in the clay litter game. However, a lot of these positives are heavily dependent on frequent litter box cleaning and maintenance, so if you prefer to have a lower maintenance litter this one might not be the one for you. 

Review rating: 5/5

Best crystal

PrettyLitter Health Monitoring Cat Litter

$34

PettyLitter has made a name for itself in the cat litter game, and for a good reason. Not only does its crystal formula eliminate odor and moisture, but it also is formulated to help you track the health of your cat. Its color-changing litter uses your cats’ urine as a guide to indicate whether they have any health issues, such as urinary tract infections, bladder inflammation, urinary stones, or blood in the urine. Plus, it’s low-dust to keep your litter boxes nice and clean. 

$34 at Amazon

Pros

• Crystal, non-clumping litter neutralizes odors and moisture without any added scents

• Uses color-changing technology to indicate potential health risks

• Low-dust

Cons

• Color-changing litter could be hard to track for multiple cats at once

• Non-clumping litter not preferred by all 

• Still tends to track around the home

Overall review

PrettyLitter is another one I’ve tested with my own cats, and I can say it’s great if you prefer a non-clumping litter. It really does neutralize the moisture to the point where cleanup is super easy once it’s time to change out the litter. Plus, the color-changing aspect is a huge benefit when tracking your cats’ health. However, it might not be the best for cats frequently sharing litter boxes, and though its low dust it does still manage to track around the house pretty easily. 

Review rating: 4/5

Best grass

Catit Go Natural Multi Cat Vanilla Scented Pea Husk Clumping Cat Litter

$25

$20

This natural litter is a great option if you prefer a natural clumping litter. It’s made out of pea husks, which is both effective at covering odors as well as soft on the paws. This clumping litter also breaks down naturally and can be safely flushed. Plus, it comes in two different natural scents, vanilla and lavender, that aren’t too overpowering and shouldn’t overwhelm your cats’ sensitive noses.

$20 at Chewy

Pros

• Natural, clumping litter made from pea husks

• Flushable

• 99 percent dust-free

• Comes in two scents: vanilla and lavender

Cons

• Scents might not appeal to all 

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

• Is more prone to tracking

Overall review

Being able to control the odor of multiple cats is essential, so we love that this pea husk litter uses both the natural scent of the peak husk material as well as the natural scents of either vanilla or lavender to really mask the scent of the litter box. Plus, its clumping formula is safe to flush and 99 percent dust-free, helping manage the mess of your multi-cat home. However, some reviewers have said that it still doesn’t totally cut down on the tracking. 

Review rating: 4.5/5

Best corn

Nature's Miracle Premium Scented Clumping Corn Cat Litter

$15

$13

Another corn-based litter on the list, this Nature’s Miracle offering is another natural litter that comes up high on our list. Its fast-clumping formula forms into tight clumps to control moisture and odor from seeping into the litter box as a whole. Its tight clumps are easy to clean, and the litter is also 99 percent dust-free.

$13 at Amazon

Pros

• Fast clumping corn cob litter

• Absorbs two times as much liquid as clay litter

• Forms tight clumps easy to scoop

• 99 percent dust-free

• Low-tracking

Cons

• Clumping litters tend to require more frequent maintenance

Overall review

There’s a reason why we’ve seen a rise in corn-based litters on the market; its natural ingredients do a great job at masking odor, and this Nature’s Miracle offering is no exception. We love that it uses natural materials to control both moisture and odor, and that it’s also super easy to clean. Plus, it’s 99 percent dust-free and low-tracking. Just note that its odor control really depends on the frequency of scooping. 

Review rating: 4/5

FAQs

What cat litter material should you buy?

There are so many options on the market nowadays, and it really comes down to both your and your cat’s preferences when it comes to texture, dust management, odor control, and tracking. For example, clay is often used in clumping litter and can help lessen the amount of dust kicked up, and natural materials such as corn or tofu can help with odor control without using additional scents. 

How do you make sure my cat’s litter is safe?

This is a more subjective question than it may seem, as all cats have their own unique health factors. Some cats are more sensitive to dust and/or have feline asthma, so using litters that kick up a lot of dust may be a less safe option for cats with pre-existing breathing problems. Another example is that sometimes when clumping litters are left unattended for too long it can create a fine dust that when ingested can cause health issues for your pets. All that is to say that litter safety has a lot to do with your own maintenance and cleaning procedures.  

What’s the difference between clumping and non-clumping litter?

Clumping litter absorbs moisture quickly and turns pee into tight clumps that are easy to scoop, and it tends to be a cleaner option as it allows you to remove smelly clumps quickly. Non-clumping litter absorbs moisture more slowly and disperses throughout the litter and requires you to change out the entire litter box every few days, rather than just pick out the smelly bits over time.